Shaker vs. Flat Panel Kitchen Cabinets
Shaker and flat-panel cabinets are the most popular types of kitchen cabinets. These are also known as framed vs. frameless cabinets. Whether you're leaning toward the classic charm of shaker cabinets or the modern appeal of flat panels, understanding the differences will help you pick the style that suits your kitchen best. This guide breaks down the history, design features, pros, and cons of each style to help you make the right choice
Why Shaker Cabinets Stand the Test of Time
Shaker cabinets have been around since the 18th century. Originally made by the Shaker religious community, these cabinets reflect the Shaker ideology of clean lines and practical design.
Shaker cabinets, like our Galaxy door style, are known for their five-piece door design, including the recessed center panel. This simple and classic look works well with many kitchen styles and is classically beautiful with a natural wood finish or painted in a crisp white.
Why People Love Them
- Versatile and timeless- Shakers look great in both traditional and contemporary styles.
- Depth and detail- The frame and panel design offer visual interest.
- Lots of options- You can choose different finishes and colors to match your style.
- Long-lasting- Built with high-quality materials, shakers withstand daily wear and tear.
Potential Drawbacks
- Attracts dust—The recessed center panel can collect dust and grime. To keep your shaker cabinets looking pristine, you will need to clean them regularly.
- Not as popular—Although shakers are considered a classic design, the more modern flat panel has been gaining popularity, with shakers falling to second place.
Embrace Modern Simplicity With Flat Panel Cabinets
Flat panel cabinets, like our Catalina door style, are all about simplicity and modernity. Their smooth, flat surfaces have zero frills, making them a favorite in modern designs.
Flat panel cabinets can be made with various materials, like plywood, solid wood, or MDF, which Fabuwood uses with all of our cabinets.
Why People Love Them
- Modern and sleek- Great for a modern and contemporary look.
- Perfect canvas- Their simple design lets hardware stand out, so choose ones that will pop.
- Easy to clean- The flat surface makes cleaning the cabinet door a breeze.
Potential Drawbacks
- Less versatile- The sleek and simple look won’t fit into all design styles.
- Simple- The straightforward design has a modern appeal and doesn’t work well with other styles.
- Shows imperfections- Scratches and nicks are more visible because there are no design details to hide them.
- Trendy- If you’re looking for a timeless kitchen design, flat panel is not for you. Shaker is the way to go if you plan to resell your home.
Comparing Shaker Cabinets and Flat Panel Cabinets
Design
Shaker cabinets: Timeless, versatile, great for modern and classic looks
Flat panel cabinets: Best for a sleek, modern, and minimalist vibe
Cost
Shaker cabinets: Our shaker, Allure style cabinets come in a range of prices- a 23% difference from the most cost-effective to the costliest shaker.
Flat panel cabinets: Our Illume style cabinet also comes in a range of prices, from the most cost-effective to the costliest; there is a 17% difference.
Installation
Shaker cabinets: These are easier to install because the face frame can compensate for uneven walls or floors.
Flat panel cabinets: More challenging to install for DIYers because any alignment errors will be noticeable. Our adjustable legs for our flat panel cabinets allow for quick and easy adjustments.
Durability and Maintenance
Shaker cabinets: Durable, needs more careful cleaning due to all the detailed features
Flat panel cabinets: Durable, easy to maintain
Aesthetics
Shaker cabinets: Perfect for a classic look that could also be contemporary
Flat panel cabinets: Great for a sleek, modern style
Resale value
Both styles will add value to your home if they are made of high-quality materials and excellent craftsmanship.
Shaker or flat panel?
Choosing between shaker and flat panel cabinets depends on your style, budget, the quality of the materials, and how much maintenance you are up for. Flat panel cabinets are perfect for a modern, easy-to-maintain, while shaker cabinets are great for a timeless appearance and if you don’t mind the extra cleaning. Mix and match the two styles for a unique and stylish kitchen.
Ultimately, your kitchen should be a space you love. Pick whichever one makes you happy! If you need help deciding, order your Allure and Illume sample doors and see how they look and feel in your kitchen.